| I'm betting St. Paul is the patron saint of online streaming. See how God is reaching down from heaven with TV waves? Like a cosmic, "Hey! St. Paul! go inspire those PBS folks to share the love!" |
Where was I?
Oh yeah. The episode.
So when Ken gets home on Monday night, we pull the two big armchairs into the kitchen, grab a some wine, and watch the show while speaking in British accents and asking where our servants are to bring us some brandy.
All this, after a day carefully spent reading the internets with one eye closed, lest I accidentally read a spoiler and then have to blurt out said spoiler to Ken because I am fundamentally unable to keep a secret.
Despite my best efforts, I kept reading that this newest episode was a Very Special Episode. Grab your kleenex. You're going to be emotionally spent.
Last night we watched it, and I came away feeling...underwhelmed.
Don't get me wrong. I liked Sybil. I liked her raspy voice and her hair and how her sweetness was a good tonic to Mary's brusqueness and Edith's whining. But I loathed Branson so, so much, that his awfulness eclipsed my enjoyment of Sybil.
But here's the real reason I didn't find this episode of Downton to be the emotional train wreck others did.
Because the episode before it killed me.
Because of this. Do you remember this? The part where Ethel Parks gives up her three or four year old son to people who despise her? This scene broke me. When I watched it, it was me kneeling there in the dust, and one of my own small sons clutching his teddy bear, completely uncomprehending the enormity of the events unfolding.
In that scene, I hated Isobel more than I ever did, for letting her dreams of being the "great white light for fallen women everywhere" get in the way of seeing this woman and child for who they were. It was only sweet Mrs. Hughes, sweet, heart as deep as the ocean Mrs. Hughes, who saw the horror of what was going on.
And I hated Ethel a bit, for refusing to take Charlie's grandparents' money that could help her keep her child and lead a healthier life, because she was so full of that poisonous mix of self-loathing and pride.
I cried during that whole scene. I endured Ken laughing at me for it. But it was so, so wrong what happened, that by the time Sybil died, I knew I had already seen something worse.
____________________________
On Sunday, when it was time to get ready for Mass, Gabriel and Jude came up with one of their ideas. They had been wearing matching Superman costumes all day, and they didn't want to take them off to put on church clothes. So they told me they were going to be Clark Kent, and sure enough, there they were in pants and collared shirts, with their Superman costumes still on underneath.
How can a mother say no to such ingenuity? So off we went to Mass, with the understanding that they had to keep their secret identity secret, and no displaying of costumes was allowed.
Then it happened. The Gloria hadn't even started, and Gabriel turned to me, "I have to go to the bathroom." I groaned. To go to the bathroom, Gabriel would have to take off his shirt entirely, untie the strings at the neck of the costume, peel off the costume halfway, pee, then put the costume back on, tie it back up, then put on and button up his shirt.
This is Gabriel we're talking about. Not exactly the best follower of multiple-step instructions.
I tasked Joaquin as "Your Brother's Keeper" and sent the two of them to the bathroom, with the shining hope that Joaquin could help his brother get redressed and back out to Mass before the Consecration.
I waited and waited.
And waited.
Ken saw it first, and I followed the line of his horrified sight to see the double doors burst open, and Gabriel fly out, Superman costume on full display, though untied and falling halfway off one shoulder.
Luckily we were in the second to last pew, which means only 1/4th of the church turned around to view Superman's semi-nude dash to his seat.
The whole thing was hilarious to me. The boy came back, whisperyelling that Joaquin couldn't put the shirt on but they didn't get any pee on it, not even a bit! And I just nodded and tried to stop cracking up as I helped Clark Kent get his clothes back on.
I love my kids so much. So much it makes my eyes burn even typing that sentence. And the thought of giving them up to anyone is something I can't wrap my mind around. If there was a single option left available to me, I'd take it. The thought of having all these moments of Mass madness and sweetness and aggravation and then saying "No more" crushes me.
I think that's why Sybil's death didn't upset me as much as it did other people. Sybil's gone. She doesn't know what she doesn't know. She's now on to face her soul's judgement, and then, depending on the outcome, she can pray for her her family.
Whether she knew it or not, Sybil was surrounded by people who loved her when she passed, and her daughter will be surrounded by people who love both mother and child.
Ethel and her son had none of this. Ethel knows what she's given up. She may feel dead inside, but she has to keep walking around among the living, and that's why that episode was so much more emotionally charged for me.
I don't know. Maybe I'm too invested in this show and need to take a step back. Concentrate on something happier- like the fabulous dresses and the dog that I'm not convinced is even real it's so motionless.
And hey, there's always the chance that the writers will make one of my fondest dreams come true- reveal Mr. Bates as Jack the Ripper and write his boring creepy butt right off the show.


The scene that got me was when Sybil's mother said good-bye to her. Ethel may one day get Charlie back but Sybil is gone forever!
ReplyDeleteI have no clue about Downton (hadn't heard of it until just now), but the sweet story of brother doing his best to help brother go pee and re-dress is wonderful. Made my eyes begin to burn, too, thinking about my little bro when we were little. I tried to help him scrub the "dirt" off his eyelid...his whole lid was bright red from our efforts. Turns out that the "dirt" wouldn't come off because it is a birthmark. We did our best, as did your boys. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteMarc, when my brother was little, my mom tried to scrub some dirt off his face that ended up being a freckle. Here's to family everywhere who try to keep faces squeaky-clean!
DeleteLove it!
DeleteOoooo.... so you don't know what else is going to happen. Might I strongly suggest not to google any of the characters as their fate ends up being the top search result.
ReplyDeletePS- I loathe, with a capitol L, Lady Mary.
I googled way too much & now I can't help but think of how this is going to play out.
DeleteI can't imagine sending off my child, but...but...but...when Ethel was ahem, making her money, the thought that her little boy was in the room with her makes me so sick that I think he's in a better place. And yeah, your boys are so sweet and cute and funny and I would have peed my pants to see them come out of the bathroom like that.
ReplyDeleteLove "whisperyelling." I can picture it all unfolding.
DeleteI thought of this same thing Colleen. That was ick.
DeleteOh Lordy, Cari. Both episodes made me break down. Both touched my mother's heart. I have an adult daughter a little older than Sybil's character, and watching her mother watching her die, suffocating while the doctors both stood there helpless, and then watching the mother say goodbye to her youngest child ("You'll always be my baby...") just ripped me apart. The scene of Ethel saying goodbye to her little boy caused the same reaction. Her saying, "I'll never see my child again..." made me literally sob out loud, and seeing her face become a tragic, horrified mask as the car drove away, the steps she took toward the car as she caught the last glimpse of her little boy...well, I was an absolute wreck. All of us who are mothers can only imagine the loss of a child - some of us, like my mother-in-law, have experienced it.
ReplyDeleteYour description of the Supermen at Mass debacle made me laugh so hard, I made the dog bark. Thanks for the early morning chuckle!
I don't really know that Ethel had a choice in careers, and as I understand things it was hard enough to get a position as even a maid in an estate. She did the best thing she could for her son. It was the absolute, most unselfish thing she could have done for him. And I know that character died, just absolutely died to watch her boy drive away.
ReplyDeleteI was on the floor.
On the upside, God bless little boys. That's hysterical!
Maybe I'm totally missing what Isobel was hoping to do for the other women, then. Wasn't she running some sort of rehabilitation program type thing for other prostitutes? Charlie's grandparents were prepared to give Ethel money, and I think between the money and Isobel's job training thingamabob, Ethel had at least one more option she could have explored. But at that point, I think she was so full of self-loathing that she couldn't see that opportunity as something she deserved to try.
DeleteI agree that Ethel was working out of a place of selflessness. Nobody could accuse her of making her decision based on her comfort, that's for certain.
How common were rehab programs like that, though? Seriously no expert here but there seems to be an air of newness to the idea.
DeleteI am in total agreement about the self-loathing. It's going to take her years to grow past her past and move on. Luckily for her on DA that should take about 3 episodes. ;)
The whole Ethel storyline really got to me too! I kept being upset that no one would step in alongside Mrs. Hughes and just give her a shake and not let her baby go to those awful people! I thought if Isobel offered Ethel an actual job she would be able to keep her child even if it still meant she was a social pariah in the town.
ReplyDeleteAnd Bates!! Arghhhh-soooo boring right?!
I don't like this season as much as the first two....and I already know I'm not going to like the rest of it.
ReplyDeleteWe watched two seasons in a few weeks and now I feel a little bit of disappointment.
I think Ethel's options were slim to none. Carson forbidding any maid (or footman) to even step foot in Isobel's house was proof of how damning it was for a woman such as she in her time. I did cry and I also thought about my own kids.
Cute story about your boys. I love that!
Both episodes were gut wretching. I think the Sybil thing hit me a bit more because the event was so traumatic, the writhing and screaming, and I had a friend diagnosed with pre-eclampsia at the time, so too close to home. But the Ethel thing definitely made me unconsciously scrunch my face and tense up and feel something tear inside me.
ReplyDeleteBut the real reason I'm commenting -- yes to Bates!! Everyone loves him but he is too vanilla to be lovable! I keep waiting, too, for something to be wrong with him. He's not believable.
Oh, and my cooler-than-he-realizes, recently retired dad was watching something on his ipad. I inquired. He said, oh, some show he stumbled upon, Downtown Abbey. I was hopping and skipping around with a goofy grin glued to my face. He just started season 1, it was so hard not to blabber on like a giddy girl about all the developments!
I cried through both episodes! Nice job, Mr. Fellowes, making a post partum woman sob two weeks in a row. When the camera panned back from the back window of the car where Charlie was waving . . . oh, man, not pretty . I think the part that gets me the most is that Charlie will be raised by such a pompous, horrid man as his grandfather, and Ethel knew that and sent him anyway! I am hoping the grandmother will be s softening influence, but she seems so cowed by the husband that I am not holding my breath.
ReplyDeleteAnd Sybil - yikes, I just knew that wasn't going to end well, but I thought it was going to be the baby who died. When Tom and Cora are kneeling by the bed, begging her to breathe? Well, that just got me.
And could Lady Mary be any colder towards Edith? I mean really, you are standing over your dead sister and you tell her that she doesn't have a snowball's chance of becoming any closer to you? Nice, Mary.
The fact that it was only mother and husband who could bear to touch the dying Sybil killed me. A whole room of people who loved her and it was obvious who loved her enough to get their hands dirty, so to speak.
DeleteYes and what about the doctors? They were just shrugging their shoulders saying there was nothing to be done. How about turning her on her side and giving her something to bite on while she was seizing, or giving her a dose of morphine..anything!! OK, I'm going to stop coming back here to read comments because I get all worked up every time!!!
DeleteCari, I was so entranced by this whole post and lost in your excellent writing with my still-reeling self from the (fictional) events of the past two weeks.
ReplyDeleteAnd then came your last sentence and I died. For real, scrape me off the floor. You killed me! Woman, you is too funny!
Magnesium sulfate! Didn't they have magnesium sulfate back then?
ReplyDeleteThey did, actually. It's been known as a therapeutic agent for eclampsia/preeclampsia since 1907.
Delete"Thank whatever saint is in charge of convincing PBS network executives to put their newest episodes online for people like me, who like to maintain a snobby "Oh, we don't have television in our house", while still watching all the television!" - That comment made me llol - literally laugh out loud. We're those people too. No cable, but TV on all the time.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, both episodes had me a total wreck. Especially since we have a new little gal who just turned one week old yesterday. The thought of giving her away - I bawled. Ugly cry. Pretty sure I would have embarrassed my husband. Then Sybil and knowing that the baby won't have her mother - bawled again. Seriously, Downton is trying to get me on anti-depressants or something.
This preeclampsia advocate (and survivor) thinks this article needs to be linked.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/01/28/beyond-downton-abbey-preeclampsia-maternal-deaths-continue-today.html
*stepping off my soap box*
That superman story made me laugh so hard that I had to read it aloud to my husband and I'm still giggling as I write this. AMAZING.
ReplyDeleteMy thoughts exactly on Bates. I hear where you are coming from with Charlie, but the thing is I have seen too much good come from adoption to feel just that way. Yeah, the dad was horribly wicked, but everybody was horribly wicked, including phoney Isobel whose pride is greater than her will to do good.
ReplyDeleteIt's funny- you're the second person to put the Ethel decision in terms of adoption. It puts the whole thing in a much different light when you look at it like that.
Delete